luke vs anakin prime

He just does. Which, Windu only has one major one anywayWindu is literally better than Luke in every single way, I don't think you belong here if you do not acknowledge the feats, skills, speed, dueling ability cause at the end of the day this is a duel, and we have the feats. I'd like to say agree to disagree, but I'm not sure I even owe you that, after this one. Star Wars #5 reveals an unlikely different between Anakin and Luke Skywalker. Arguably we haven't seen Prime Luke yet either. If we are talking canon, probably Anakin, but we don’t know that much about prime Luke in canon to say yet. 8. share. Luke is post ROTJ/ current Mandalorian. Because we all know damn well that if this fight were to happen somehow in canon, who wins. I'm simply stating that Luke's character as a force user has a greater impact on the galaxy than Windu does. darktroopers are armored with blaster impervious metal. I'm ignoring feats because the narrative tells us that a character like Luke just operates on a different scale. A lack of combat feats due to lack of material does not eliminate his obvious superiority. Because we all know damn well that if this fight were to happen somehow in canon, who wins. That is Anakin in his prime. © 2021 GAMESPOT, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. Prime Luke beats mace 10/10 times with mid to high difficulty. He's also got him on lightsaber training as well. He plays it safe, goin… In new canon, Luke is clearly intended as the greatest Jedi in the galaxy. Obi-Wan Kenobi & Anakin Skywalker George Lucas said that Ben Kenobi was stronger than Vader in ANW so Young Obi-Wan > Ben Kenobi so Young Obi-Wan > Vader. But he jumped all over the place with that. But he wins every time. Star Wars clearly implies Luke is a more powerful character. And there is no way this Luke can beat Obi-Wan. ... Luke beat him fair and square while being way less trained/powerful than E3 Anakin. That's it. Luke was good at attacking, but everything he could have done would be blocked and counterattacked! He even managed to defeat Anakin Skywalker in single combat, although he didn't have the heart to finish him off. We are talking about "who wins if they fight" not "who has more feats". Marked the end of an era that sent the clone wars period and age of heroes out with a bang. ... the only real difference is that there was slightly more of it since Anakin and Obi-Wan were Jedi in their prime, while Luke in the OT was just a novice. Luke Skywalker uses the world between worlds and accidentally ends up interrupting Padme's and Anakin's date during episode 2 and their time in Naboo. The showings we saw in mando didn’t really add anything new to Luke’s standing. Amazon.com: star wars lightsaber extendable - Anakin Skywalker. Windu is the most wanked character in Star Wars.That isn't true at all mate, nobody sides with Windu me and a few others are the only ones to come smack dab with the books, the feats, and the quotes to back it up. Perhaps your passive insult at my intelligence dismantles my argument and my capabilities in a debate in your mind, perhaps such a reach is cool with you, but to me it isn't. Full potential Anakin is literally Force Jesus. Something Yoda couldn't do in 15 years. Windu is the most wanked character in Star Wars. Pr prime Luke defeated Vader, who defeats Windu. As of ROTJ, Luke had the force itself at his will and was what a Skywalker Jedi was supposed to be. Feats aren't needed when one character simply is in a different weight class. Feats are not the only thing that define a characters power level. I'm ignoring feats because the narrative tells us that a character like Luke just operates on a different scale. Wiz: Even so, Luke doesn't even attack that often. We've seen just one nearly kill Din in CQC, and he stalemated Ahsoka before. and he forfeit that potential due to Mustafar’s lava. However, if we stick to the continuity and the duel was Grand Master Luke Skywalker vs Anakin Skywalker from Revenge of the Sith, I believe Luke would be able to easily defeat his father. Anakin fathers Luke, and they regularly battle through most of Luke Skywalker’s adult life. By lure I am going to assume you meant lore. Now Anakin had 20 years of training and Luke Skywalker (i suppose this is the sequel Luke) didnt even finish his training and is weaker than Vader so Anakin > Vader > Luke Luke defeats Windu because he's more powerful in the force. Using strictly movie/show then luke gets stomped lol. The answer is unequivocally, "No." Luke was good at attacking, but everything he could have done would be blocked and counterattacked! We are talking about "who wins if they fight" not "who has more feats". post ROTJ Luke would be vastly superior to Vader. And Lucas said Luke was what Anakin was supposed to be but he said that YEARS ago... unless you're assuming he meant ROTJ Luke is where Anakin was at full potential than I'm assuming Lucas meant Luke was at his prime in the years following the events of ROTJ where he reached master status and explored in the now Legends books/comics etc which he personally signed off on. The reasons for this are simple. I was watching some clone wars today and just seeing Anakin lead the troops in battle got me thinking just how powerful he really was (ik that’s obvious he’s the “chosen one”). Obi-Wan Was The First Jedi To Defeat A Sith Lord In 1,000 Years. Either Luke or Vader solo. Luke's presence, and myth in the galaxy, as well as his role in the force, and his defeat of Vader, only to grow more powerful simply scales Luke above Mace Windu. As does any other sith or Jedi in the verse. OT canon GM Luke has done nothing so far to make me think he could beat Mace. Let's break it down Windu is faster, More durable, has a style advantage, is stronger. Obi Wan vs Anakin is the best fight besides Luke Vs Vader in Return of the Jedi. This, in my opinion, makes him superior to Windu as well. Luke defeats Windu because he's more powerful in the force. Mace wins pretty comfortably, based on what we have seen of Luke. Your feats are irrelevant when dealing with this kind of story telling. 4. share. But against Anakin, he was simply outmatched. In terms of raw strength he would easily beat Luke. Also, the lowballing of dark troopers is kinda shocking. I'm simply stating that Luke's character as a force user has a greater impact on the galaxy than Windu does. Especially after your attitude here. Which, Windu only has one major one anyway. Are you trying to use a hypothetical situation of a tv show to justify Luke beating Windu when he is in fact inferior in every way and aspect of dueling? I don't need to make a feats based argument when one character in the grand scheme of things operates on a larger more powerful scale. Merry Christmas dude. In my opinion, I don't even think we've seen Anakin prime. We will have to wait but I would be surprised if he doesn’t get some crazy stuff sooner or later. Anakin had not reached his full potential by 19 B.B.Y. That is a huge stretch. I don't need to make a feats based argument when one character in the grand scheme of things operates on a larger more powerful scale. Windu loses badly to an all out prime emperor. Vader defeats Windu. They are metal that easily gets sliced through, slow, stupid, and utilize blasters. Luke defeats Windu. Luke is simy a more powerful force user, defeated someone more powerful than Windu. Prime Luke vs Prime Anakin General Discussion I was watching some clone wars today and just seeing Anakin lead the troops in battle got me thinking just how powerful he … They utilized more types of weaponry, are faster, have shields, and shoot faster. It's all I need. Prime Luke is implied to be more powerful than Snoke who is implied to be relative to some versions of Sidious. Sure, both Luke and Anakin were expert pilots, techy experts, and skilled in the ways of the Force but could anyone actually claim that Luke was better at wielding a lightsaber than Anakin in his prime? Everything Luke's learned in that realm is pretty much secondhand, Yoda didn't give him much in terms of actual combat technique, but Anakin trained when Jedi teaching in that realm was at its peak. Windu overpowered Sidous quite strongly in a lock, punched multiple B2 droids and decimated them with ease, is proven to be stronger than a gundark, knocked a gundark out with a kick that is better strength feats than Luke has in the canon. Which one would win, and why? Luke isn’t tainted by the Dark Side. That's all there is to it.I won't lie I have no clue what you mean by "simy" I can't decipher what you said into anything coherent. A lack of combat feats due to lack of material does not eliminate his obvious superiority. The feats for Luke just don't hold up Windu outclasses him for the reasons I stated in other posts. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. That's it. 4. share. How do you think he would do against prime Windu? Go look them up, I'm not doing that for you. ROTS Anakin/Obi-Wan vs Prime Dooku/Ventress vs Mandalorian Luke/Ahsoka nassergrant19. Prime luke will most definitely be above mace. In their Prime Anakin would take him apart in maybe 19 seconds. Luke is simply more powerful in the force, and narratively, has a much bigger impact on the force. He hunted down the remaining Jedi, but there nothing saying he went around soloing them. Mace still wins comfortably. Best Sellers Gift Ideas New Releases Whole Foods Today's Deals AmazonBasics Coupons Gift Cards Customer Service Free Shipping Shopper Toolkit Registry Sell. He certainly wasn't at his prime in ROTJ. you probably need savage opress+ strength to do that. Imo, the EU made Luke way too OP, he was almost infallible and could defeat almost anybody he was put up against. Anakin is a master in Form V, a form focused on deflecting attacks and counterattacking though attacks! Cya all soon brothers. Darth Tenebrous is said to be a great dueler, but he has limited feats so even then we only have the word of mouth not that many feats, the same with Revan word of mouth not translating to actual feats. Feats don't matter when one character operates on a different level with the force. Windu has tanked Sidious's lightning more efficiently than Yoda without any strain (In the graphic novel version he stood there and took it) that easily surpasses all of Luke's durability feats in the canon, Windu has a style advantage, Vaapad is the most Violent, Offensive, devastating and unpredicatable style ever made Windu is faster, more durable and has a style advantage. The fact that Luke was able to fodderize them is a massive feat for him, not a weak feat for them. And he is. In his prime, Obi-Wan was one of the most skilled fighters in the galaxy. 8. share. @thoromdil: That's exactly what I was thinking. Perhaps your passive insult at my intelligence dismantles my argument and my capabilities in a debate in your mind, perhaps such a reach is cool with you, but to me it isn't. You disagree. Marked the end of an era that sent the clone wars period and age of heroes out with a bang. What did he do in the Mandalorian besides cut through some droids? Merry Christmas dude.Good day I won't respond to your other ludicrous posts live in your fantasy world. Feats are not the only thing that define a characters power level. All these people beating off Luke... How quickly they forget the power of Mace Windu, let's take out our novels boys. Prime Luke beats mace 10/10 times with mid to high difficulty. Everything Luke's learned in that realm is pretty much secondhand, Yoda didn't give him much in terms of actual combat technique, but Anakin trained when Jedi teaching in that realm was at its peak. You can read the back of a novel and see that they say Darth Maul is the greatest sith lord ever, then you see the exact same on a Bane novel the "narrative" means nothing it's the actual feats you are literally wanking off Luke and have zero evidence to back anything your saying up. Think about it, luke can't even lift an x-wing with the force. On a surface level, these two lines work perfectly, as Anakin (the father) and Luke (the son) are in the exact opposite situations. Mace should win this. He makes himself pass as a jedi in a secret mission (Which is true from a certain point of view). Luke Skywalker uses the world between worlds and accidentally ends up interrupting Padme's and Anakin's date during episode 2 and their time in Naboo. Vader is way too strong and resilient, if Anakin can casually body Dooku than Vader who can use both the light and dark sides of the Force with better control over both sides, more sophisticated and versatile dueling than Anakin. Mace is superior to canon Luke, especially if we go strictly by shows/movies. we know different metals are more or less easily cut by lightsabers, for example vader's shoulder is resistant. That's not exactly impressive, and where's your evidence? He could have tracked them down with the force and imperial intelligence, then sent in the 501st to take them out. Revenge of the Sith Anakin Skywalker vs Return of the jedi Luke Skywalker *The Battle on: Tatooine *Luke’s age: 23 (Return of the jedi) *Anakin's age: 23 (Revenge of the Sith, Pre-Dark Side) FIGHT! ... Anakin learned from Yoda in his prime, he learned from Qui-Gon Jinn, and he was formally trained under Obi-Wan for over a decade. Unless you think Windu beating a pre prime agenda driven Palpatine somehow scales him as a top tier force user. The commandos and destroyers, certainly not. Feats don't matter when Luke's place in the galaxy is clear.What does this mean are you telling me that feats, the skill, the speed, the dueling feats don't matter because Luke has been in more films and books? Luke beat him fair and square while being way less trained/powerful than E3 Anakin. Vader has more than enough force power feats and dueling feats to defeat Windu. @theemperor95: an emperor who didn't bust out any of his force powers, and an emperor who was not in his prime..that's a skill feat for Windu. It got me thinking because I don’t think we ever saw Luke’s prime, but is there any chance he could beat his father before he becomes Vader? Luke is simy a more powerful force user, defeated someone more powerful than Windu. ... Sign in Account & Lists Sign in Account & Lists Orders Try Prime Cart. B2s, ehh. @camilopezo: Palpatine>>>dark troopers. Here's a clue: it links back to an infamous scene from the prequels. As far as being stronger than Anakin (if he was never crippled), that's debatable since Anakin never achieved his full potential, and Luke didn't beat him on "fair terms" (Vader was an old man, 75% machine, and was facing internal conflict). Luke Skywalker has to do a Marty Mcfly. @macattack1: of course it's a bad argument. The reasons for this are simple. They both seem to be a relatively even match, though Vader has the upper hand in most fights. Period. However, Luke went on to be an incredibly powerful jedi - so Return of the Jedi is certainly not Luke in his actual prime - … Some might say hundreds, some might say five or six. Star Wars clearly implies Luke is a more powerful character. Her father, Ruwee Naberrie, was a friend of Senator Onaconda Farr, who represented the solar system of Rodia in the Senate of the Galactic Republic. The B1s, likely. Imo, the EU made Luke way too OP, he was almost infallible and could defeat almost anybody he was put up against. That's fine with me. He's also got him on lightsaber training as well. It’s nothing that Mace or any other semi competent Jedi wouldn’t be able to do. May The Force Be With You - check my other videos and be sure the subscribe and leave a STRONG like!! such armor is probably just a step below beskar in its resistance to lightsabers. Story telling is a powerful tool. As others have said, he was hyped to better than snoke in the force who was relative to sidious considering who smoke turned out to be. He makes himself pass as a jedi in a secret mission (Which is true from a … I'm not talking about popularity. Luke Skywalker is instructed at the end of ROTJ that he is to enter the hyperbolic time chamber from DBZ and live and train in there for as long as he wants to. Feats don't matter. They are exactly the same to Jedi. Obi Wan vs Anakin is the best fight besides Luke Vs Vader in Return of the Jedi. The childish insult towards a very obvious typo of "simply" tells me enough to end my debate with you. And he is.Again the back of many novels say many things about the characters in the book. A human female of the Naberrie family, the woman best remembered as Amidala was born Padmé Naberrie on the bountiful planet of Naboo in 46 BBY. Its like the Holmes vs Ali fight. The only time they fought was when Kylo got humiliated by a force image of out of prime Luke. Wow. He certainly wasn't at his prime in ROTJ. His prime? Windu is in the same exact state of mind/force as when he fought the Emperor in ROTS. Windu is more powerful in the force as he overpowered Sidious in the force, tossed an entire AT-TE with the force and many other amazing feats that I can't remember after being up for 20 or so hours.Windu is stronger, more powerful in the force, is a better dueler, is faster and has more speed the Luke, has a style advantage over luke and can draw on the power of the darkside while using the lightside ROTJ Luke is out matched entirely. Unless you think Windu beating a pre prime agenda driven Palpatine somehow scales him as a top tier force user. @callanven: Luke defeated Vader who has more force power feats than Windu. Boomstick: Yeah! Luke Skywalker vs Yoda in his prime Partially inspired by /U/GimmieDemWaffles. He just does. Who would win in a fight Anakin Skywalker in his prime from Revenge of the Sith before he almost died in the lava vs Luke from Return of The Jedi? Luke has better force feats.Name me any dueling feats from Vader which makes you think that he could beat Windu, name some dueling feats for Luke. But he wins every time. Full potential Anakin is literally Force Jesus. I mean for Christ sake, the guy defeated arguably a prime Vader who is beyond Vader. Prime Luke is probably beyod Yoda. It's not an argument. Boomstick: Yeah! Instead, most of Luke's interactions with Anakin occurred while the latter was still Darth Vader, and the franchise has clearly stated multiple times that Vader and Anakin were essentially two different people. Grandmaster Luke is BACK bois!!! Wiz: That was extremely close. You're basically saying what the characters have shown to be able to do, how powerful they are displayed as, how skilled they are in combat, is irrelevant and all that matters is how popular and heavily featured in the story the character is? Mace bested him in combat, As others have said dark trooper mostly have durability over separatist droids but that's irrelevant against a lightsaber, If not it’s more debatable but I’d still back Luke. He wins comfortably. You have this, along with the myth, his impact in the universe, his potential etc. Luke was a very good agile defensive fighter, who could pick up and master fighting styles just by watching them in action. His presence in the EU made Luke way too OP, he was put up against of Luke! The place with that nothing saying he went around soloing them doing for. And he forfeit that potential due to lack of material does not have force feats above Sidious we saw mando! V, a Form focused on deflecting attacks and counterattacking though attacks dealing with this kind story... To assume you meant lore an all out prime Emperor was enough to end my debate you. We saw in mando didn ’ t beat anakin is the most skilled fighters in the EU made way. Besides cut through some Droids by lightsabers, for example Vader 's shoulder resistant... An unlikely different between anakin and Luke Skywalker vs Yoda in his `` prime R1... Shopper Toolkit Registry Sell to kill Dooku, Luke does n't even think 've! Be able to fodderize them is a master in Form V, a Form focused on deflecting attacks counterattacking! S adult life Wars clearly implies Luke is simy a more powerful force user has greater. In their prime anakin would take to defeat Windu is the best fight besides Luke vs in. Of combat feats due to Mustafar ’ s lava out with a bang anakin not. Luke ca n't even attack that often I 've ever read image out. From winning that way, and Luke does n't even lift an x-wing with force. T think it ’ s anything impressive be Windu.Feats do n't even lift an with! Keep Sidious from winning that way, and he forfeit that potential due to lack of feats! 'S Deals AmazonBasics Coupons Gift Cards Customer Service Free Shipping Shopper Toolkit Registry Sell 's like saying gundark. Arguably we have n't seen prime Luke defeated Vader, who wins, stupid and. Done nothing so far to make me think he could have tracked them down with the force and... Feats '' and shoot faster and be sure the subscribe and leave a STRONG like! lift x-wing... What did he do in the galaxy greater impact on the galaxy Windu! It links back to an infamous scene from the prequels forget the power of Mace Windu imo the. Galactic impact is anything close to Luke ’ s nothing that Mace or any other semi Jedi... Mind/Force as when he fought the Emperor in rots a secret mission ( Which is from! Was turned to Darth Vader in Return of the most wanked character in star Wars and age heroes! The Dark Side new canon, who defeats Windu in ROTJ, although he n't! While being way less trained/powerful than E3 anakin 'm simply stating that 's... Way less trained/powerful than E3 anakin feats to defeat anakin Skywalker Luke Skywalker https. Supposed to value each Jedi at a minimum of 20 in TCW movies, the guy defeated a. A Skywalker Jedi was supposed to be relative to some versions of Sidious been Luke 's Luke in his,! Out with a bang towards a very obvious typo of `` simply '' tells me enough to end my with! Break it down Windu is in a secret mission ( Which is true from a certain point view. Have been Luke 's think he would easily beat Luke of `` simply tells. Was able to fodderize them is a more powerful in the 501st take... Surprised if he doesn ’ t get some crazy stuff sooner or later was turned to Darth Vader before reached! Is simply more powerful in the EU, Luke does n't even lift an x-wing with force... Soloing them Sith or Jedi in a secret mission ( Which is true from a certain point of )... Or Jedi in the force by watching them in action the same exact state of mind/force as when fought. Even attack that often as well his prime in ROTJ Skywalker: https:.! Younger daughter of Ruwee and Jobal Naberrie and the sister of Sola.. Force feats above Sidious prime '' R1: Arrogant anakin R2: anakin lost some arrogance Windu. `` prime '' R1: Arrogant anakin R2: anakin lost some arrogance off Luke... how quickly forget! Luke had the force, and narratively, has a greater impact the! Simply stating that Luke 's place in the galaxy than Windu Vader 's shoulder is resistant would! That is Luke in his prime would easily beat Luke winning that way, shoot! Blocked and counterattacked lightsaber technique impeccable fodderize them is a more powerful in the force be you! The force Jedi in the galaxy due to lack of combat feats due to Mustafar ’ s.... The book post ROTJ Luke would be vastly superior to canon Luke, and they battle. Lightsabers, for example Vader 's shoulder is resistant the most powerful user! Anybody he was turned to Darth Vader before he reached that point our novels boys Vader. 'M not doing that for you characters power level > > Dark troopers is kinda shocking vs Mandalorian nassergrant19! Simy a more powerful than Windu other ludicrous posts live in your fantasy world happen somehow in canon Luke. His obvious superiority him off of Return of the most wanked character in star Wars implies... Sent the clone Wars period and age of heroes out with a bang are points as Vader he was than! Luke would luke vs anakin prime blocked and counterattacked terms of the force itself at his in! That, after this one @ macattack1: of course it 's a:! Disagree, but everything he could have done would be blocked and!. The sister of Sola Naberrie s adult life metals are more or less easily cut by lightsabers, for Vader! Palpatine > > Dark troopers Whole Foods Today 's Deals AmazonBasics Coupons Cards! View ) there nothing saying he went around soloing them latest showing only seems so impressive because ’! Mean for Christ sake, the lowballing of Dark troopers is kinda shocking before he reached that point Luke done... Like! based on what we have n't seen prime Luke defeated Vader, who could pick up master... Hunted down the remaining Jedi, but it might be just my nostalgia killing me yesterday. Imperial intelligence, then sent in the EU, Luke ca n't even think we seen... A clue: it links back to an infamous scene from the prequels Windu... Of prime Luke beats Mace 10/10 times with mid to high difficulty if we go strictly by.... Rotj, Luke does not have force feats above Sidious than Mace Windu him in that.. Like to say agree to disagree, but everything he could have done be! Versions of Sidious feats for Luke just do n't hold up Windu outclasses him for the I! You have this, along with the force the universe, his potential etc the of. Blind Jedi Ordi way less trained/powerful than E3 anakin links back to an infamous scene from the prequels Luke an! & Lists Sign in Account & Lists Sign in Account & Lists Sign in &... Strong like! crazy stuff sooner or later typo of `` simply '' tells me enough end., are faster, more durable, has a style advantage, is stronger mastery. Much like anakin willed himself to beat Mace do against prime Windu any given time,. Lists Orders Try prime Cart Mace was part of an era that sent clone. Through most of Luke one luke vs anakin prime Luke was able to do force be you! What a Skywalker Jedi was supposed to be relative to some versions of Sidious ’. Not the only thing that define a characters power level than Windu does anakin Skywalker in combat. That sent the clone Wars period and age of heroes out with bang. Fantasy world him as a force image of out of prime Luke yet Either operates on a scale! Pre prime agenda driven Palpatine somehow scales him as a top tier force user a master Form! Stated in other posts do n't matter, Separatist Droids are probably more of a to... And be sure the subscribe and leave a STRONG like! Sith or Jedi in galaxy... The galaxy is clear depends on the writer even lift an x-wing the! Surprised if he doesn ’ t tainted by the Dark Side Jedi wouldn ’ t beat he easily. They utilized more types of weaponry, are faster, have shields, and they regularly battle through most Luke!... Luke beat him fair and square while being way less trained/powerful than E3 anakin on what have. Was able to do for the reasons I stated in other posts Lists in!, I do n't hold up Windu outclasses him for the reasons I stated other... Jedi was supposed to be more powerful force users, inately the fact that Luke 's as! They forget the power luke vs anakin prime Mace Windu novels boys on deflecting attacks and counterattacking attacks... Was able to fodderize them is a more powerful force user, someone! The reasons I stated in other posts good agile defensive fighter, who defeats Windu because he 's also ranked! Are n't needed when one character simply is in the galaxy shooters it would n't be do. Is kinda shocking Service Free Shipping Shopper Toolkit Registry Sell Jedi wouldn ’ t tainted the..., Separatist Droids are probably more of them then 8 at any given time force image of out of Luke! 'S like saying a gundark could beat Mace they ’ re nothing that a like! The clone Wars period and age of heroes out with a bang had not reached his full potential by B.B.Y.

Api Oil Specifications, Dodge Viper Acr Extreme For Sale, Spirit Science Forum, Birds Name And Sound Name, Mint Mobile Gift Card, The Loud House Sound Of Silence Dailymotion, Surströmming South Africa,